The ticking time – bomb in our property markets

The ticking time – bomb in our property markets

Quite surprising that nothing has been said when last Friday, the Australian government debt ticked just over $475 billion. For the last twelve months, the government on average has been borrowing $6.35 billion each month, so what happens when they hit the debt ceiling of $500 billion? Will that then bring an end to Australia’s prized membership of the AAA – rated club?

Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s and Fitch have just 9 countries in the AAA club – Australia, Canada, Denmark, Germany, Luxembourg, Norway, Singapore, Sweden and Switzerland. Should our membership be revoked that would mean that borrowing costs would increase overnight, which is not a good sign for the Australian economy. The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) currently estimates that Australian small businesses currently owe $13 billion in unpaid tax debts. Obviously, there is no impact on existing debt although when it comes time to refinance then that would be an entirely different story.

With the federal government recently weighing into the housing affordability debacle there are two things that I would immediately implement to critique our housing markets.

      1. The ATO has taken over responsibility for being Australia’s biggest property manager so land banking must be the first point of call. It is estimated that Sydney now has well over 100,000 permanently vacant apartments so they should be rented out to ease the rental crisis. Look at the lost revenues the ATO is missing out on with these land banked properties, where the clear majority are owned by overseas investors. Land banking in Australia must be outlawed.


      2. Reverse the ridiculous off – the – plan ratio back to 50 per cent from 100 per cent to overseas buyers. We are now going into the ninth year of 100 per cent and the only clear impact we are seeing is that foreign investors have become a most dominant player. In 2016, Chinese developers acquired almost 40 per cent of the Australian residential sites that were offered to the marketplace. All these properties are offered exclusively to Asia and these properties are not available for local buyers. Reducing the ratio back to 50 per cent would have a big impact on housing affordability.

A recent survey by Roy Morgan Research found that approximately 7 per cent of Australian mortgage holders have little or zero equity in their homes in the twelve months to October 2016. That would equate to approximately 300,000 properties across Australia. Western Australia has the highest number with 54,000, followed by South Australia with 27,000, Queensland with 63,000, Melbourne has 50,000, Victoria has 65,000, NSW has 73,000 and Sydney has 33,000. Tasmania came in with 5,000 – these are concerning numbers when you consider the east coast has enjoyed unprecedented capital appreciation.

Since 2009, Sydney home values have doubled and Melbourne have climbed 85 per cent. In 2011, less than 10 per cent of investors held multiple investment properties, according to Digital Finance Analytics. This has now grown to 16 per cent nationally, and on the east coast multiple investment properties is now approximately 18 per cent.

Really makes one wonder, just what data our elected politicians and policy makers are actually looking at or quite possibly, they don’t even understand this data?

The most recent data from CoreLogic shows that the rental yields in Sydney and Melbourne are on the decline. For Sydney, houses yield is 2.8 per cent and units are 3.8 percent. In Melbourne, houses are 2.7 per cent and units are 4.0 per cent. It will be most interesting to see just how low these yields will go with all the new developments entering the market. It is quite clear that investors have been enjoying the unprecedented capital growth over rental yields in Sydney and Melbourne, although this is about to change.

With very few alternate investment opportunities, we don’t at this particular point in time expect to see investors retreating out of the market, although we do expect to see carnage in the CBD markets. This should not come as a great surprise as these markets have introduced thousands and thousands of new apartments, and many suburbs have constructed less than one hundred new apartments.

Whatever the case, if you like watching real estate machinations 2017 will keep you highly entertained.

To add to this, the Commonwealth Bank advised mortgage brokers this week, that from February 13, it will cease accepting refinancing applications for investment home loans. Will the other major lenders then follow suit?

MOSMAN – 2088

Number of houses on the market this time last year – 53

Number of houses on the market last week – 39

Number of houses on the market this week – 43

Number of apartments on the market this time last year – 46

Number of apartments on the market last week – 31

Number of apartments on the market this week – 36


Number of houses on the market this time last year – 17

Number of houses on the market last week – 10

Number of houses on the market this week – 12

Number of apartments on the market this time last year – 17

Number of apartments on the market last week – 15

Number of apartments on the market this week – 14


Number of houses on the market this time last year – 9

Number of houses on the market last week – 2

Number of houses on the market this week – 5

Number of apartments on the market this time last year – 27

Number of apartments on the market last week – 15

Number of apartments on the market this week – 18

Source: pricefinder

7 Responses to “The ticking time – bomb in our property markets”

  • Owen Moore says:

    Good article bob!
    Any idea what the government are spending the $6B a month on?

  • Rob Simeon says:


    It would be fascinating to see exactly what the $6.000 billion breakdown is although we both know we will never see that. Maybe the Opposition Leader might ask? He has been devoid of intelligent questions this week.

  • Ann says:

    Yes agree 100% Robert, land banking needs to stop and that will force affordability in the market.

    On the debt, we elected muppets and they are true to form.

  • sarah says:

    what exactly do you mean by ‘carnage in the CBD markets?’ and when do you expect to see it?

    • Rob Simeon says:


      In some areas there will be a massive oversupply of apartments all chasing tenants so it will be difficult for all these properties to secure tenants. What we have already see is rents at much lower figures than what was initially anticipated. In some developments there are thousands of apartments which might explain why in some areas the banks have shut – down all future funding.

  • bugalugs says:

    The government should turn this into a benefit for Australians. Let Australians buy their first three homes stamp duty free. Permanent residents buy their first one with 10%, the second 20% and the third 25%. And foreigners pay 20% stamp duty on the first dwelling and then 25% on the second and then 50% on the third. Cap all individuals at 3 dwellings max. Then tie the tax raised to improving infrastructure – public transport, roads etc….

    Then get rid of this nonsensical low density housing mere 5kms from the city. Rezone it all high density within 5 kms and medium density within 10. That will improve supply.

    That will slow demand, raise revenue, and improve public infrastructure. It’s not really rocket science.

    Oh yeah, get rid of either local or state government so the government stop paying politicians for nothing really. That will help with the government spending/debt and hence help with maintaining the triple A rating.

  • Dennis Pallos says:

    A good report Rob

    certainly Australian land banking has a huge effect on the rental market.

    As for National debt (still rising).
    Well it started with the Kevin 07. the Labour Party has to be held accountable for wreckless spending.

    To fix it? Simple but extremely difficult.
    Welfare spending is out of control and 3 times that of its next villain.
    The public Service is too large and sluggish, it literally is , adult day care in the main,Excepting those in essential services of course) for those who wish to contribute nothing to the good fortune of this nation.

    Sadly, the Nation has developed a mind set of expectation and selfishness. Caused by left wing , social engineers,apologists.Labour, Greens and some independents. (in politically incorrect oldspeak, they are called , ” bludgers” ).

    Essentially, to have half a chance of real Australia, saving itself. We need to start with a major overhaul of the Electoral System. That is , one vote one value, and shock horror, eliminate compulsory voting.

    the real

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *